J Calanthe ([info]jcalanthe) wrote,
@ 2008-11-29 02:22:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Entry tags:angela montenegro, bones, cam saroyan, csi, hulu, jack hodgins, jared booth, queer, seeley booth, temperance brennan, the closer, trans, white privilege

Bones eps 406, 407, 408, 409, plus trans characters in procedurals
Ever since a comment in [info]callmesandy's lj pointed me to Hulu, I've been watching all sorts of TV, including recent Bones eps. I'd forgotten how much I really like this show, and pretty much every character on it.

I keep misreading one episode title as The Skull in the Scripture (instead of sculpture, ep 407), which is all the more hilarious given the episode. Dude, Best. Episode. Ever! Angela is now canonically bisexual! Makes my Bones/Angela all that much closer to canon. I adore that they made her relationship in art school be a year long, so it wasn't just a bicurious fling, and that there was no Oh yes, I experimented in college but am over that now that I am a real adult nonsense. Someday, I hope to live in a time when I don't celebrate every single queer character on TV because they're commonplace, but for now? Queer woman of color on my TV (well, computer, it's Hulu), I'm dancing with joy. And I loved Booth's story about his aunt.

I'm now watching The Con Man In the Meth Lab (ep 408), and I already love it even before the opening credits. ZOMG, Booth has a brother! Who is also hot! The only thing that could have made his introduction better is if Hodgins had come over and flirted with him too. And the contrast between Jared who is good at politics and Seeley the straight-shooter is an interesting one.

Also interesting that they're not taking it the way I expected, but instead with the whole DUI thing (I guess I should have seen some character flaw for Jared coming, but I was distracted by the blinding hotness of Jared in Navy dress uniform). I do have to admit I'm disappointed to find that Booth's hot Navy brother is an alcoholic - him as a recurring love interest for, well, anyone (other than his brother, which these days in fandom I feel like I need to stipulate) would have worked for me. But the storyline with Bones and the brothers Booth ended up way more interesting than the jealousy angle I expected them to play to death. Though I gotta say, at this point, it's out of character for Bones to think S. Booth is a loser, regardless of what his brother or anyone else said. The scene at the end, where Bones knows to ask if Booth needs space as well as time, that's much more them, and an excellent scene with a lot of body language and not a lot of words.

I do like it when pop culture shows people struggling with being family to addicts, and raises the idea of enabling and how hard it is to stop (and why it's important to). That whole arc is ridiculously accelerated through the magic of TV time, but aside from the speed, I think the storyline was well done - the charismatic, risk-taking brother who fools just about everyone, the older brother who looks out for the younger brother regardless of personal cost (I've certainly been that guy) & who's unwilling to criticize him or let anyone around him do so, how being children of alcoholics affected the two of them. I generally watch Bones because it's more fluffy than a lot of the crime procedurals - the characters in general get along, it's less gratuitously gory (and when it is, it's in a scientific way mostly), murder & so forth are usually not made sexy - but it's nice for it to sometimes have some depth too, and without being too message-y because it comes from character development.

Also, hooray for more Eugene Byrd! I totally love Clark's professional boundaries thing. I especially like that he & Cam are the only ones who talk professional boundaries - I think it's realistic to have POC being more concerned with that, since white people get away with so much more shit and therefore have the privilege to not be so concerned with such things. Of course, a few minutes later, they have Clark oogle Bones's cleavage, followed by Cam giving Bones advice about the brothers Booth in front of Clark, which undercuts that whole idea, but I'll stand by it as they actually raise the concept of appropriate conduct (I suppose Bones does sometimes too, but I think only with her lab assistant, and not consistently).

I feel like I should say something about The He in the She (ep 406, which I watched earlier in the week), and really, I feel mixed about it. I think it's interesting that the whole forensics on TV thing has led to multiple trans eps on various shows. The whole idea that DNA could actually mislead investigators is too good for writers to pass up, and it's given us more trans characters in mainstream TV than anything else I can think of, with varying degrees of sensitivity/offensiveness.

Wandering away from TV for a moment, in this day and age of identifying remains through DNA, it is something I think about - no one's going to find my remains that way, at least not without some inside information. I know, in the grand scheme of things, if I'm killed in a way that only DNA can identify what's left, gender isn't really going to be that important in the grand scheme of things, but still, one more thing for my loved ones to have to negotiate, and if for some reason they're not around either, I could end up "unknown female remains" forever. But I digress.

Unfortunately, the structure of procedurals limits us to transfolk as perps, transfolk as victims, and transfolk as suspects (since of course the moment a character's transness is revealed, they become a suspect for having a "secret worth killing over" - CSI did a nasty bit with this). I think CSI had the first evil tranny (mmm stereotypes), with their recurring FTM villain - at the time I was excited to just see an FTM on TV, and I liked that he outsmarted Grissom of all people. NCIS embraced the idea too with an MTF villain, capped with a joke in the next ep about kissing a man - it was so offensive I almost stopped watching the show.

CSI definitely has embraced the poor pathetic tranny stereotype, with trans characters as victims of crimes, and with MTF witnesses/friends/family in one ep I've tried to block from my memory. And while I thought it was actually pretty well done, there's an ep of The Closer where the FTM manages to fit both stereotypes (and possibly not even be trans but just living as a man to hide from law enforcement, though I'm not sure we know for sure since everything we learn about the trans character was from people who didn't know and from the killer, who was horribly horribly homophobic and transphobic). We have managed to expand to transfolk killed not because they're trans, as in Bones 406 - this victim isn't portrayed as pathetic at all, and I think her transness was irrelevant to her murder, and I do appreciate that.

Thinking about it, I'm not sure I've ever seen an ep where the trans character was presented as being out and totally accepted by their community, and where the community was not mocked for being accepting. And it was so nice to see an MTF on TV who's not a sex worker (I hear that there's another character on Ugly Betty as well, but I don't watch that), and who's not all into the bar scene, drugs, etc. And yet also not portrayed as totally stereotypically Stepford-wife female.

I hated hated hated all the crap that came out of Booth's mouth, but I appreciated that he got called out on it repeatedly, and by so many different people and in different ways. And I thought the religion angle was interesting, that both father and son struggled with being part of a fundamentalist sect and how to reconcile their faith with who they were, and I like that this got expanded to more than just transfolk. I'd have to rewatch, but I think this one was a definite improvement over the last Bones ep with a trans character.

On to The Passenger in the Oven, ep 409. I do love the Bones-Booth interaction at the beginning of the ep, and for all people mock David Boreanaz's acting, he's very good with his enjoyment of the first class seat (and I'm amazed that he could enjoy a massage chair that much without it being explicitly pornographic).

I'm also enjoying the mystery fan, and the portrayal of a fan as intelligent - a nice change from some of the fan mockery on other shows (I'm looking at you, Aaron Sorkin).

Oh man, the naughty librarian thing from Booth - totally awesome. I laughed so hard, [info]bearfairie wanted to know what was going on. And the followup where she experiments with doing what he asked to try and figure out wtf was also good.

And more queer women, yay! I figure, the artist is probably only around for a short run (presumably they're getting Angela & Hodgins back together at some point), so I gotta enjoy it while I can.



(12 comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]cedara
2008-11-29 11:04 am UTC (link)
Booth's library kink was too charming. :-)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]jcalanthe
2009-03-18 10:12 am UTC (link)
Very belatedly, yes indeed! I'm remembering how charming it was all over again now.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]ratcreature
2008-11-29 11:11 am UTC (link)
And it was so nice to see an MTF on TV who's not a sex worker
Yeah. I think that is just about as rare as seeing someone with a mental illness that involves hallucinations or delusions on tv without them being serial killers or the like.

(Reply to this)


[info]ide_cyan
2008-11-29 12:46 pm UTC (link)
Cold Squad had a pre-transition MTF character for a couple of episodes, in one of its middle seasons (4th one, maybe? I think? before Harper replaced Coscarella), who was just an ordinary detective worried about how transitioning would affect his job, though I don't remember what happened to the character after that plot thread was raised.

ETA: found the episode I was thinking about. It's from S3.

Edited at 2008-11-29 12:54 pm UTC

(Reply to this)

I Don't Get to Talk Bones Much. . . .
[info]shadowandstar
2008-11-29 04:37 pm UTC (link)
I really, really like Bones. My daughter and I have a weekly pizza-and-Bones date that we always keep. But although I really like the characters and the series overall, I haven't been too happy recently.

First, I've been feeling a bit jerked around by the writers this season: the procession of oddball lab assistants, Angela and Hodgins being broken up, Sweets mostly being set up for comic effect (almost the Jar-Jar Binks of the series) but every so often given a chance to actually do his job. It's as if, after building things up with Zach's removal and breaking A&H up they're now just spinning us.

I wish they would hire Clark and give Sweets some professional dignity -- inlcuding some professional boundaries where his co-workers are concerned.

I had some strong feelings about the way the writers handled Bones' whole "alpha male" bit. (Posted at my primary journal here:
http://feral-journey.livejournal.com/765881.html But I did love that last scene between them in the bus kiosk.

One of the things I always liked about the Angela-Hodgins relationship was that they were both so unabashedly, joyously sensual. Angela being bisexual seems completely consistent with her character. What I don't like is that the writers seem to have dropped the issue which broke them up in the first place: Angela's territoriality over her ex-husband, Hodgins' dismay over that, and Angela's accusations of jealousy and control. Instead we have Hodgins asking if her bisexuality was the issue.

Finally, while I liked the airplane episode, I was dismayed by the extent to which the family at the center of the crime was treated as little more than a McGuffin, rather than addressing the tragedy. Personally, I don't care if it's my one chance in a shortened lifetime to see the Great Wall: if my kid is being taken back to the US on murder charges, I'm going back with her. In the last scene, Bones and Booth treated the kid like a truancy case, not a desperate, grief-stricken teenager who had just committed murder because someone was hurting is terminally ill mother. One of the things I really liked about previous seasons was that the pain of the victims -- and often that of the perpetrators -- was taken seriously, while maintaining some of the lighter elements that make the show charming. Now the comedy is taking a front seat, and it's diminishing the quality of the series, IMO.

(Reply to this)


[info]wearemany
2008-11-29 05:52 pm UTC (link)
Cold Case has had by far the best track record for any crime procedural on queer and gender related cases, i think. certainly their gay ones have had a really thoughtful take, and usually their history holds up quite well. it's a crime procedural, so it's not that surprising i guess that the best one i can think of still has trans=victim.

here's a long, detailed recap for "Daniela" (with moderately problematic language, but in general a fair retelling). i'm not sure it actually captures how much the one guy's love for daniela comes through on screen -- it's one of a number of Cold Case eps where people actually handle being queer or falling in love with a trans person better than anyone gives them credit for. the misdirection in the episode is that the "suspect" totally dealt with whatever unexpected course love took -- even if those around them couldn't handle it so well (and therefore reacted w/ violence).

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]k2daisy
2008-11-29 10:54 pm UTC (link)
Cold Case does give its gay and gendered stories a lot of depth and dignity; I just happened to remember today the one where the girl who wanted to be a boy and ended up lobotomized. The character was so vibrant, her ending was utterly heartbreaking! Just thinking about the last scenes with her best friend/love made me well up.

I've been watching a few Bones eps lately, and it's a pretty fun show. I don't know why I never watched it before; it must conflict with one of my other shows. Hmm.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]wearemany
2008-11-29 11:22 pm UTC (link)
oh, i totally haven't seen that Cold Case. do you know the episode title? i'll have to tivo it the next time through.

you're right that that show in general has a greater sense of dignity about it regardless of the victims -- maybe it's because of the cold case set up, where it's a slightly more "heroic" kind of police work being represented, "just trying to answer questions," like that. but they also are smarter in writing about sexuality, gender and race than the other procedurals.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]k2daisy
2008-11-30 12:19 am UTC (link)
Had to do some looking around, but it was Boy Crazy. S5, so it may still be available online or in reruns.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]poisontaster
2008-11-29 07:51 pm UTC (link)
For police procedurals, there's not a whole lot of respect or respectful characterization for most LGBT characters and a small part of that, as you point out, is the genre, where everyone who's not a regular is a villain, victim or suspect, but also just...lame writing.

Ugly Betty does have a trans character (whose role they recently reduced drastically) and they do a better job of portrayal, but they still sometimes still fall into the bad habit of playing the stereotype for laughs.

The show that I really am applauding for it's trans portrayal is Dirty Sexy Money, where one of the characters (up for election as a Senator) is having a deeply passionate love affair with a MTF character (and the actress, Candis Cayne is trans, herself) and it's not played as anything BUT a genuine love affair between two people who care about each other deeply. Too bad the show just got canceled.

(Reply to this)


[info]fighter_chick
2008-11-29 08:45 pm UTC (link)
America's Next Top Model has a MTF trans contestant last season. Hardly a great portrayal, but you can make a pretty strong argument that ANTM doesn't portray any woman of any persuasion well.

My personal wish is to see a chronic pain patient on a medical drama who's *not* a lying drug addict just looking to get high. I suppose we all have our dreams!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]jcalanthe
2009-03-18 10:19 am UTC (link)
*laughs* Yea, I have a few opinions on ANTM, and one would include that it doesn't portray any woman of any persuasion well. But then, I have watched all of 5 minutes of it cuz I just could not watch any more, so I have little basis for my opinions.

a chronic pain patient on a medical drama who's *not* a lying drug addict just looking to get high

Well, that's just the crazy talk, cuz you know they don't exist in real life. *rolls eyes* House has done some somewhat interesting stuff with this - the ep where they show the backstory behind his leg injury, part of why it gets so bad is he's initially identified to be drug-seeking & so they don't help him. But that's the closest I can come up with, and of course the show can't make up its mind about whether he's an addict, in pain, or possibly both.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


(12 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…